Dean and Sam arrive at the Pineview Hotel after Chuck Shurley calls them. Dean pauses briefly when he notices other Impalas in the parking lot. However, they find Chuck and asks what’s going on. He has no idea why they are there, and they explain that he texted them and said it was a life-and-death situation. Chuck realizes that Supernatural book fan Becky called them, just as Becky comes out.
He realizes she took his phone and apologizes to the brothers as he goes into the hotel. They follow him and find one man dressed as Dean, and another as a scarecrow. They realize that everyone there is dressed like characters from their lives. Becky explains that it’s the first Supernatural convention.
The convention begins and an embarrassed “Carver Edlund” (Chuck) takes the stage. He takes questions and the first one is where he got the idea of Sam and Dean. Finally asks what happens after the last book, and Chuck says that thanks to a Scandinavian investor, they’re going to start publishing again. Afterward, Chuck tries to approach Becky but Sam and Dean interrupt to tell Chuck they don’t have the time to deal with his issues. They ask who gave him the right to publish more books, but Chuck insists that he needs the money. He gets them in private and explains that he’s neither a hero nor a talented writer, and he needs to live until the world ends. Suddenly a scream rings out and they go to investigate. A maid says she saw a ghost in an old-fashioned dress. The brothers soon realize the maid is an actress, and Becky explains that the attendees are holding a live action role-playing game. Becky figures Sam and Dean will win.
