As they prepare for a surprise shower, Nick and Abby set up their significant others to keep Billie and Zack occupied. The plan turns into a disaster when the arranged couples don’t get along.
Hoping not to ruin their Christmas, Billie tries to keep the fact that Zack is living with her from her parents. Meanwhile, Nick makes an effort to impress his father-in-law.
Billie and Zack attend separate parenting classes due to a conflict in their schedules. Accompanied by Olivia and Abby, Billie faces competition from her sister who does better in the assigned tasks.
After James employs a new movie critic for the newspaper, Billie sees her job in peril and starts showing her value to her boss.
